Short Film Review: ‘The Perfect Tomato’ – the undeniable bond between family, sacrifice and the sense of achievement

Cristobal Abugaber’s beautifully crafted short film, ‘The Perfect Tomato‘, captures the essence of resilience, love, and the undeniable bond between family, sacrifice and the connection to all that we work for. With a runtime of just 18 minutes, it delivers an emotionally rich narrative that lingers long after the credits roll.

This short is about an ageing farmer, Nacho, who refuses to leave his longstanding way of life behind at the risk of losing what truly matters to him. The story unfolds delicately, offering a poignant reflection on tradition, sacrifice, and the inevitability of change.

Eligio Meléndez takes on the role of Nacho, embodying a strong-willed yet loving father and grandfather. He paints the perfect picture of a hardworking man who has dedicated his life not only to the tomato fields but also to the family he holds dear. Eligio Meléndez’s performance is both tender and powerful, making it easy to believe in Nacho’s struggles and unwavering sense of duty. His life has been defined by service not merely as a choice, but as a responsibility born out of love for his daughter, Elena who also has a daughter of her own, little María.

Elena, portrayed with equal brilliance by María Meléndez, is a mother with her dreams and aspirations. A skilled potter, she shares over dinner that a college has offered to collaborate with her to open a pottery store. A venture that would require her to move to the city. She proposes that Nacho join them and encourages him to accept a promotion that would free him from the demands of the tomato fields. Her eyes glisten with passion and optimism as she discusses this opportunity, a testament to her hard work and vision for a better future.

But for Nacho, the decision isn’t simple. “The field is my life and not a page in a book,” he says, resisting the idea of leaving behind the home he and his late wife built over the years. His reluctance is more than fear of change. It’s about holding on to the memories, the connection to the land, and the legacy that defines him. Despite his declining health, Nacho clings to the belief that he can continue to work in the fields as long as his body allows, a testament to his determination and pride.

The collaboration between Cristobal Abugaber and cinematographer Brendan Sweeney elevates the film’s storytelling. The visuals are a feast for the eyes, with well-composed shots and bright natural colours that capture the raw beauty of the struggles faced by Nacho and Elena. Each frame is a reflection of their emotional journey, using lights and shadows that emphasize both hope and hardship.

The dialogue, entirely in Spanish, is accompanied by English subtitles, but the film’s sound design ensures the emotional weight of every word is felt. When Nacho tells little María in the opening scenes, “Harvesting is the prize that plants give us for taking care of them and letting them grow,” the sentiment resonates deeply when you think about it. Nothing good does come easy, it requires planting, nurturing, and waiting for the right time to reap the rewards.

The Perfect Tomato masterfully balances its narrative, carrying the story at an even pace that keeps the audience engaged from start to finish. Its simplicity is its strength, showcasing relatable characters and a heartfelt plot that feels universal.

The film’s message is clear. The sacrifices we make for the people and places we love are what truly define us. “The land has given us everything, and it’s the same land that will continue to form your clay.” Nacho shares these words with Elena towards the climax of the film. And that too reflects the need for us to never lose hope in all our strive.

With its moving message, stunning visuals, and exceptional performances, ‘The Perfect Tomato’ is a brilliant short film that leaves a lasting impression. It’s a story so rich in heart that you’ll wish it didn’t end with this short film.

I will score this a perfect 5 stars.